Originally posted by X
View Post
By the way, that article/post on the contradictions must have been written by a simpleton. When the manager says he has final say, it is clearly not on the financial aspects. So for example, even if Ayre came up with the money for Dempsey, he wouldn't be in the squad if Rodgers didn't want him. BR has say on who, IA has say on how much - pretty standard business model.
Other examples of simplistic interpretations:
1. Spending power - the club DOES have the spending power to match anyone, but to spend their money stupidly is clearly not part of their intention. So buying Dempsey for £6m to then go buy Sturridge for £12m is not a matter of money, but internal financial controls. A variance on budgets can be had for anything.
2. Contracts are not signings - this one takes the cake. It is clear the club will consider experienced signings - what is also clear is that they are not going to pay over the top for it.
3. Balanced squad - the simpleton who wrote the post claims that if we were a balanced squad, we'd be doing better than 8th. He clearly doesn't understand the nuances at play.
4. Moving Goal Posts - he complains that a top 4 for KD is now not the standard for BR. Give BR £80m to spend and I am sure top 8 won't be acceptable either. It's not a matter of moving the goal posts, but getting the club on track towards a more realistic objective based on where we are now.
5. Clear Vision - he implies there is not. I disagree. The focus is on youth. Eleven of the following 20 first team players are 25 or younger:
(Pepe Reina, Daniel Agger, Sebastián Coates, Martin Skrtel, José Enrique, Glen Johnson, Andre Wisdom, Lucas Leiva, Steven Gerrard, Jordan Henderson, Joe Allen, Jonjo Shelvey, Stewart Downing, Suso, Oussama Assaidi, Daniel Sturridge, Raheem Sterling, Luis Suárez,Fabio Borini, Carragher).
Of this lot, Wisdom and Sterling came from the youth system, Robinson, Flannagan, Kelly are also players who played first team ball for the club this year from our youth system.
6. Experience at the top - one can't argue with this as it is true, but it is a bit disingenuous. "Experience" sometimes clouds the way forward as people do bring baggage with them. However, there's no question that experience is a big deal. FSG clearly believe in on the job experience being adequate for key positions. We will see if they are right.
Leave a comment: