RBSC

Collapse

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Stick to the job you were hired to do, Mr Simoes

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Paul Marin
    replied
    Originally posted by Karl View Post
    In one particualr article - I said, either "Our schools are..." or "The schools are..." our academies. Currently that is still the case. I even spent some time on explaining why it would make sense to improve the teaching of/coaching of football in schools - We get the kids from 'the cradle'...and lose them/let them go/they go off at 16 through 19+.

    Some of the things I can remember off the top of my head - in no particular order
    i) Captive numbers of willing pupils.
    ii) Investment in physical plants by the government and private sector.
    iii) Cost sharing - staff, physical structure, training of coaches (via teachers colleges and outside experts)
    iv) Ease of...use of...administration
    Karl,

    I am not sure if you're being entirely appreciative of the "academy" system as it exists in europe and elsewhere and why the schoolboy system is not going to provide equivalency. First though, let me say that I do agree that we have to use the school system as ONE part of the puzzle, it is not the answer however and not necessarily worth exploring.

    Here's why I say this. Remember that the academy system is a COMPETITIVE RECRUITING system. This means that clubs actively scout, recruit and develop players to feed a private or community sponsored enterprise. Because they pull from such a large pool (unlike a school that pulls only from its students) this makes the academy itself (in theory) more elitist so in a city like Kingston, you would have say 10 academies with 100 elite players from age 5 through 18 progressively developing skills based on a common set of standards.

    I don't believe this can be accomplished with the schoolboy system as schools won't have the necessary focus to deliver the quality output required. For example, no individual school would have a large enough pool of boys to pull from. As I understand it, the way academies work is that they take any boy from anywhere and invest in that youth's development 365 days a year. That is unrealistic in schools under current systems especially from an adminstrative point of view. Secondly, with a proper academy system, you would get top talent playing with top talent, so a great player from Calabar would be in the same academy as a top player from JC etc. Also, remember that the schools primary focus is to educate, not develop athletes.

    The question now becomes how to get academies in place. That is a very tough problem to solve, but it can be done as they do not have to be based on the European model initially. Secondly, I suspect that there are creative ways of aligning Jamaican clubs with foreign clubs in joint development initiatives, but I admit that this is a supposition on my part.

    The bottom line though is that the solution to the problem is not simple and it is unlikey as I see it that the schools are the solution. I'd rather they focus on teaching the three "R's" properly.

    ~Paul

    Leave a comment:


  • Karl
    replied
    Originally posted by pHoQrY View Post
    the article was rubbish...took Simoes' utterances way out of context, and has made the haters float to the top. Mi caaan believe it!

    The man distinctly said that our school football program should not continue to be the catalyst for our national program in the long run. Instead, we should try to get the clubs to take up the mantle. He said, that schools are essentially for academics, while clubs are for football, so the clubs would have a greater interest in the proper development of our young ballers.

    How comes nobody nuh post wah di man did seh...anybody can get it...Karl????


    dem a tear di man down same way...and di man a talk truths. Is it only obvious to the blind that if our clubs were to take it up, it would be better for us in the long run?

    Jah know...mi feel a way afta mi read da article deh...

    Even if he said what you said it does not make sense. There is no reason to stop using the schools as discovery, condiut for and a place where development of footballers occur.

    I am sure no one would think for even one moment that the schools should be the alpha and omega of football development on the island...but to suggest that the schools do not have a long term role to play in development of players is, in my opinion, a nonsense posture!

    The aims should be simple. Improve the training that takes place in the schools & in all other venues (including clubs and the proposed academies). Why someone would suggest that the schools either cease preparing footballers and or cease having an important role to play in development of same I cannot understand.

    Leave a comment:


  • Paul Marin
    replied
    Originally posted by Bricktop View Post
    Brazil, Argentina, Italy, France, Spain, Netherlands, Germany are the top teams in the world today and they all have one thing in common. Take a guess what that is?
    GUESS: None of them have never had foreign national team coaches.

    Leave a comment:


  • Peter R
    replied
    Quick question for anyone: is there any restriction on the level of school (i.e. junior sec vs HS) to participate in Manning or Dcup? I've been away long so tell me, is there a tier system with schools being relegated and promoted etc.

    If this is the situation then definitely ALL the available talent will not be captured by HS. And since the season is relatively short, just how much development takes place.

    What did Mike Lee Chin advise on the other forum? find a mentor(system) and copy it til you perfect it.

    pr

    Leave a comment:


  • Peter R
    replied
    I can tell you what the High school coaches are telling the boys here in T&T. My son happens to play U14 for his HS and the coach at his school has instructed them all to become affiliated to a club, i.e. Joe Public, Jabloteh, Rangers etc. ALL the starters of his team are so affiliated.

    The seasons do not coincide. Like in JA the clubs at the teen level (or at any level) do not have the following that the High Schools have but I believe that being a part of a larger organization helps the kids understand better what success will entail. HS is more for prestige and glamor and to satisfy the egos of the Old Boys (btw I plead guilty).

    pr

    Leave a comment:


  • Muadib
    replied
    Yuh nuh si who write it ?

    Yuh muss recognize a corrupt individual and how dem move.

    Leave a comment:


  • Peter R
    replied
    The author has a (biased) agenda.

    pr

    Leave a comment:


  • Muadib
    replied
    It must be a generational thing.

    In my time and a few years after Campion won a few Sunlight Cups, Pepsi, Colts and Under-15.

    What year yuh left Wolmers ?

    Leave a comment:


  • pHoQrY
    replied
    the article was rubbish...took Simoes' utterances way out of context, and has made the haters float to the top. Mi caaan believe it!

    The man distinctly said that our school football program should not continue to be the catalyst for our national program in the long run. Instead, we should try to get the clubs to take up the mantle. He said, that schools are essentially for academics, while clubs are for football, so the clubs would have a greater interest in the proper development of our young ballers.

    How comes nobody nuh post wah di man did seh...anybody can get it...Karl????


    dem a tear di man down same way...and di man a talk truths. Is it only obvious to the blind that if our clubs were to take it up, it would be better for us in the long run?

    Jah know...mi feel a way afta mi read da article deh...

    Leave a comment:


  • Mosiah
    replied
    heh heh! a bet yuh coulden critically think like dem doh!

    Leave a comment:


  • Culture Sound
    replied
    Oh zeen..to me when we did play them inna cricket the match ago done early so wi can go a half way tree game shop

    Leave a comment:


  • Mosiah
    replied
    I used to love beat dem at Schools Challenge Quiz!

    Leave a comment:


  • Culture Sound
    replied
    Mi nah disrespect the thing...but truth is truth...mi did just a call out one school name...but mi nah lie mi use to love play gainst Campion inna football and especially Cricket

    Leave a comment:


  • Reggae-Fan
    replied
    What were the exact comments made by Simoes regarding the local schoolboy competition? And what makes his comment wrong given the context in which he speaks? As far as I know simoes speaks within the context of Jamaica's football development (I woukd be surprised if it were otherwise). I wonder how many talented footballers over the years never really got a chance to develope their football skills when it mattered most simply because they didnt get the chance to play d cup or manning cup for one of the elite schools? 2-3 months for the entire year is hardly adequate time for any player at any player in any league or division to properly develope their playing skills.

    The writer of the article was just trying to eat a food.

    Leave a comment:


  • Muadib
    replied
    Ask him again.. him mussi nuh know bout Campion Under-15 record...

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X