RBSC
Collapse
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Stick to the job you were hired to do, Mr Simoes
Collapse
X
-
He was right then and he would still be right today.Originally posted by Muadib View PostMaybe Simoes is right ?
The 'writer' does not refute the statement.
Apparantly there is no room for constructive criticism in the 'writers' world.
A microcosm of why Jamaica is struggling as a nation.
Leave a comment:
-
Test!
...just checking if an article from waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay back can be brought forward! ...mmmm? Lata will try 1 from even further back in time!
Leave a comment:
-
Point taken!Originally posted by Peter R View PostKarl,
The problem is not Simoes, it is people like Paul Reid who might not be accurately reporting Simoes'the words. Don't you see a pattern here in the articles he writes? Did Simoes really say we should "dump" the school system? i don't know the answer but again, like the article on the Trelawny Stadium an Burrell, I'd like to see and hear what Simoes himself said with respect to the schools.
The point is that while the article is an opinion piece we must base our opinion on factual occurrence rather than a narrow interpretation of what the speaker intended.
pr
Leave a comment:
-
I like the words "narrow interpretation" as I have found this particular writer does have a narrow perception of most issues. He seem to limit his view on what he hears just to get a story.The point is that while the article is an opinion piece we must base our opinion on factual occurrence rather than a narrow interpretation of what the speaker intended.
Leave a comment:
-
Karl,
The problem is not Simoes, it is people like Paul Reid who might not be accurately reporting Simoes'the words. Don't you see a pattern here in the articles he writes? Did Simoes really say we should "dump" the school system? i don't know the answer but again, like the article on the Trelawny Stadium an Burrell, I'd like to see and hear what Simoes himself said with respect to the schools.
The point is that while the article is an opinion piece we must base our opinion on factual occurrence rather than a narrow interpretation of what the speaker intended.
pr
Leave a comment:
-
Bredren...my apologies for not making my argument more clear for you to understand. What I' trying to say to you is Simoes argument was about advancing our football beyond where it is, in the long run. His belief is that our footballers would be better served by being involved in a setup that concentrates on the game. At no point is there an advocation for the removal of school football, all that is being suggested is a more direct approach to advancement in the game.Originally posted by Karl View PostWell if the curriculum at an academic is football only...then the lack of exposing the minds to other disciplines will be seen in falling numbers of quality products from the academy. That academy I think will start turning out poor footballers...footballers who have a problem fitting in on the field...limited minds...poor minds...as it were, unthinking footballers!
Broadening the players scope? ...better serve our football?
Ofcourse!
...but that is not what you meant. Somehow it appears to me that you think our footballers must necessary be fools! That would not be 'good'! ...or for that matter a sensible way of thinking.
Karl, when u going to try and discredit someones writing, try and delete the part that does not relate to the argument you pushing. For if you noticed, reading the entire paragraph shows that your statement is way out of context, making your conclusion nonsensical iya.
On your second response...now that you agree with the broadening of our scope...let me reword it so as to ensure that you are not totally obliterating your arguments.
it is essential to recognize that in expanding our methods used in achieving full potential from our footballers, it may be necessary to develop outlets of concentrated learning, so as to increase our football growth level.
...dis fool fool baller argument nuh mek it bredren, how yu fi bring up dat, how yu come to dat conclusion not even mek sense iya...straighten up and fly right !
Leave a comment:
-
.... So if there is a focus on balls and brains then improve the level of play in the manning and d cup. Don't scrap them for football academies.Originally posted by Karl View PostWhy do you think it is difficult to play at the highest level and be book smart at the same time?
Do you think playing a game somehow wipes the mind clean of the ability to learn other academic subjects? Why sacriface either the game or the other area(s) of discipline?
Leave a comment:
-
Agreed!Originally posted by Culture Sound View PostI beleive in the academy...but the education system can suffer if it isn't implemented right...the only way that it won't suffer is if the academy is not only for football but also an institution for learning.
I am for what you say...but additionally I think there will have to be some place for the 20-22 year olds if only as 'finishing school' for those excellent players not taken by professional club at an earlier age.Basically it should not be an alternative for school and it should not be an establishment separate from school,
There would have to be excellent Sports Management Company and Football Agent working to make things happen for these 'late developers (...and others).
The thing about school..i.e. going to classes is the lure to attend has its pull in how good were the teachers in stimulating interest in the kids and the quality of the school-class environment at the earliest (earlier) years. If the teaching was excellent...which means the school-class environment was excellent. Good teachers and teaching...have kids 'running' to school-class. In college there was the saying if the pupils found the subject 'difficult', the teacher was failing! i.e. nothing is hard (for the pupils) when enjoyable...nothing is hard (for the pupils) when it is being enjoyed! I am saying if the academic work is enjoyable...the footballers will not 'skip'!...because lets face it them won't go class....put it on a scale go class now then play ball later, or kick back till later and then go play some ball.Last edited by Karl; May 29, 2008, 10:26 PM.
Leave a comment:
-
I beleive in the academy...but the education system can suffer if it isn't implemented right...the only way that it won't suffer is if the academy is not only for football but also an institution for learning. Basically it should not be an alternative for school and it should not be an establishment separate from school, because lets face it them won't go class....put it on a scale go class now then play ball later, or kick back till later and then go play some ball.
Leave a comment:
-
Well if the curriculum at an academic is football only...then the lack of exposing the minds to other disciplines will be seen in falling numbers of quality products from the academy. That academy I think will start turning out poor footballers...footballers who have a problem fitting in on the field...limited minds...poor minds...as it were, unthinking footballers!Originally posted by pHoQrY View PostDoes the curriculum of a school only entail football? Ofcourse not, therefore the concentration necessary to develop the full potential of the young baller is never reached. Hence, the underdevelopment of our talents. Don't you see the rational? If schools decide that the game football no longer feeds the role to development, then it will be discontinued, what then for those young ones who have talent?
Broadening the players scope? ...better serve our football?Come on Karl, no myopic thoughts iya...long term, big picture...come on man! The hurry come up attitude limits our potential, broadening our scope by allowing the opportunity for entire growth will serve better for our football, don't you think?
Ofcourse!
...but that is not what you meant. Somehow it appears to me that you think our footballers must necessary be fools! That would not be 'good'! ...or for that matter a sensible way of thinking.Last edited by Karl; May 29, 2008, 09:47 PM.
Leave a comment:
-
Why do you think it is difficult to play at the highest level and be book smart at the same time?Originally posted by Time View PostSimoes needs to understand that we are not going to sacrifice education for the national team.
Do you think playing a game somehow wipes the mind clean of the ability to learn other academic subjects? Why sacrifice either of the game or the other area(s) of discipline?Last edited by Karl; May 30, 2008, 09:44 AM.
Leave a comment:
-
Does the curriculum of a school only entail football? Ofcourse not, therefore the concentration necessary to develop the full potential of the young baller is never reached. Hence, the underdevelopment of our talents. Don't you see the rational? If schools decide that the game football no longer feeds the role to development, then it will be discontinued, what then for those young ones who have talent?Originally posted by Karl View PostEven if he said what you said it does not make sense. There is no reason to stop using the schools as discovery, condiut for and a place where development of footballers occur.
I am sure no one would think for even one moment that the schools should be the alpha and omega of football development on the island...but to suggest that the schools do not have a long term role to play in development of players is, in my opinion, a nonsense posture!
The aims should be simple. Improve the training that takes place in the schools & in all other venues (including clubs and the proposed academies). Why someone would suggest that the schools either cease preparing footballers and or cease having an important role to play in development of same I cannot understand.
Come on Karl, no myopic thoughts iya...long term, big picture...come on man! The hurry come up attitude limits our potential, broadening our scope by allowing the opportunity for entire growth will serve better for our football, don't you think?
Leave a comment:
mosiah mi KNOW yuh neva read it!
Leave a comment: